HONOLULU (HawaiiNewsNow) – The jury in the attempted murder trial of a Maui doctor accused of trying to kill his wife is deliberating the case.

The judge instructed the jury to consider five counts, from attempted murder in the second degree to assault in the third degree, a petty misdemeanor.

Prosecution: A planned attempt to kill

In closing arguments, prosecutor Joel Garner said Maui anesthesiologist Gerhardt Konig tried to kill his wife Arielle by trying to push her off a cliff, attempting to stab her with a syringe, and striking her with a rock multiple times.

He showed graphic side-by-side photos of the two, and noted two hikers came upon the couple during the incident.

Garner said Gerhardt told his son, Emile, he wanted to kill her, and said the motive was an obsession over an affair.

Defense: Injuries, motive, and self-defense

Defense attorney Thomas Otake said Arielle was hurt, but argued the injuries were not consistent with an attempted murder, and that Gerhardt did not try to kill her.

He said Arielle started the fight, tried to push him over the cliff, hit him once with a rock, and that he hit her in self-defense.

Otake said Arielle would have received $1.5 million from Gerhardt’s life insurance policy.

The defense said Arielle’s story defies logic, reason, and common sense, and that much of the scuffle was a matter of conflicting accounts.

He said in an emotional call to Emile, Konig “was trying to say good-bye. This was not a confession they are making it out to be.”

What’s at stake

The potential penalties range from life with parole for attempted murder down to 30 days for petty assault, depending on who the jury believes, unless they acquit on all the charges.

HONOLULU (AP) — An anesthesiologist accused of trying to kill his wife during a cliffside hike near a popular scenic lookout in Hawaii struck her so hard with a rock that pieces of it broke off in her scalp, a prosecutor told jurors before they began deliberating Tuesday.

___

EDITOR’S NOTE: This story includes discussion of domestic violence. If you or someone you know needs help, please call the national domestic violence hotline: 1-800-799-7233 in the U.S.

___

Gerhardt Konig, 47, had a plan and backup plans for murdering his wife, Arielle Konig, during a weekend trip to Honolulu for her birthday in March 2025, deputy prosecutor Joel Garner said. He tried to push her off a cliff, and when that didn’t work he tried to stab her with a syringe filled with an unknown substance.

And when that didn’t work, he grabbed the rock, Garner said.

“Every backup plan ends in Arielle’s death,” Garner said, displaying the rock and photos of her injuries.

The doctor’s lawyer told jurors Tuesday there were no such plans, and he repeatedly sought to cast doubt on Arielle Konig’s account. Gerhardt Konig has pleaded not guilty to attempted murder, and he insists he was defending himself from his wife, who he says attacked him with the rock first.

If Gerhardt Konig had wanted to kill his wife and had access to a syringe in a remote area, attorney Thomas Otake suggested, wouldn’t he have drugged her and then thrown her from the cliff, rather than having started a scuffle before attempting to fill the syringe as he was wrestling with her?

“You would use the syringe first,” Otake said. “It makes no sense.”

The trial started last month, nearly a year after Gerhadt and Arielle Konig went on a hike on the Pali Puka trail in Honolulu that ended with her bloodied and screaming that he had tried to kill her.

Their two young sons stayed home on Maui while the Konigs were on the trip. Near a lookout offering sweeping views, Gerhardt Konig — upset about his wife’s relationship with a coworker — attacked her, Garner said. It was only because two other hikers interrupted the assault that he stopped, Garner said.

The trial, with testimony livestreamed by Court TV, has aired the couple’s marital problems leading up to the hike, along with their versions of what happened on the trail.

Gerhardt Konig testified that his wife was having an affair, which he confirmed by unlocking her phone while she slept. The relationship, which Arielle Konig characterized as an “emotional affair” involving flirty messages with a coworker, came up during the hike.

Arielle Konig testified that her husband grabbed her and moved her toward the cliff’s edge but she threw herself on the ground in an attempt to hold on. He straddled her and had a syringe in his hand, she said, but she batted it away. She bit his forearm and squeezed his testicles in attempt to get him off her, she said.

Her husband denied pushing her toward the edge and testified that she hit him with a rock on the side of his face. He wrestled the rock away and hit her with it twice in self-defense, he said.

“He reacted, and then he felt horrible about it,” Otake said. “He never wanted to hurt her.”

But the prosecutor told the jury that all of the blood found on the rock and on clothing belonged to Arielle Konig, not her husband.

Gerhardt Konig also denied having any syringes on the mountain, or trying to stab his wife. His defense attorney said no syringe was found at the scene because he never had one.

Otake said Gerhardt Konig was not someone who would try to commit murder, but someone who was struggling with infidelity and trying to do his best. Otake quoted from a heart-shaped birthday card Gerhardt Konig had written to his wife, calling her “the heart of our family” and saying, “The kids and I hit the jackpot with you.”

Gerhardt Konig testified that as he watched his wife crawl away, he believed his marriage and career were over, and he decided to jump to his death. But first, he called his adult son from a previous marriage. The son told authorities that his father said he “tried to kill your stepmom” — a confession Gerhardt Konig denied having made.

During that call, the defendant made no reference to having struck his wife in self-defense, Garner said.

He spent about eight hours hiding on the mountain before deciding to come down, and even then he tried to flee when confronted by police, Garner said.

His wife has since filed for divorce.

___