Chapter 1: A Chilling Arrival
It was a cold morning in Rockford, Illinois when the world first saw Dr. Michael McKe in a way no one expected. The vascular surgeon, once respected and admired in his field, entered the courtroom in a jail-issued jumpsuit, hands cuffed, face unreadable. When asked for his name, he responded calmly: “Michael McKe.”
The charges against him were nothing short of shocking. He stood accused of driving more than six hours in the dead of night, crossing state lines, and committing a crime that would leave a family shattered and a community searching for answers. The victims: his ex-wife, Mon’nique Ty, and her husband, Dr. Spencer Tepe, found dead in their Columbus, Ohio home with their young children present but unharmed.
How does a surgeon become a suspect in such a horrific crime? The journey to that answer began years before, in the corridors of Ohio State University.
Chapter 2: Fragments of a Past Life
Michael McKe was a native Ohioan. After graduating from Ohio State in 2014, he pursued residency in Roanoke, Virginia. It was at OSU that he met Mon’nique Ty. Their relationship blossomed quickly, culminating in a wedding in 2015. But the marriage lasted just two years.
Court documents painted a picture of a couple who had grown apart. Mon’nique was awarded the divorce on the grounds of incompatibility. Michael kept the Virginia home; Mon’nique returned to Ohio. They had no children together, and—according to public records—their split was amicable.
Michael built a new life in Illinois, earning licenses in both Illinois and California. He settled into a luxury condo in Lincoln Park, Chicago, and began practicing as a vascular surgeon in Rockford. Mon’nique, meanwhile, found her own happiness. She met Spencer Tepe online, a dentist with a reputation for kindness and dedication. Together, they built a family in Columbus.
Chapter 3: The New Beginning
Spencer and Mon’nique married in 2020, celebrating with friends and family in a joyful ceremony. Spencer was known for his love of Ohio State football, his devotion to his patients, and his infectious optimism. Mon’nique, with a degree in early childhood education, became a stay-at-home mom to their two children, ages four and one.
Their home in Columbus was a hub of warmth and activity. Friends described them as the “life of the party,” always eager to welcome others, always ready to lend a hand. Mon’nique loved to bake; Spencer loved to talk sports. Their children were the center of their world.
But on December 30th, everything changed.
Chapter 4: The Day Everything Changed
The alarm bells first rang at Spencer’s dental office in Athens, Ohio, 75 miles from Columbus. Spencer was always punctual, always reliable. When he failed to show up for work, concern quickly turned to fear. His boss, vacationing in Florida, called 911 to request a wellness check.
Police responded, but a mistake sent them to the wrong address. Meanwhile, friends arrived at the Tepe home, knocking on doors, hearing the children inside but unable to get a response. The tension escalated until a second 911 call revealed the grim reality: there was a body inside.
When officers finally entered the home, they found Spencer and Mon’nique dead in their bedroom—Spencer shot multiple times, Mon’nique with a single gunshot wound to the chest. The children, miraculously, were unharmed.
Chapter 5: The Investigation Begins
Detectives faced a perplexing scene. There were no signs of forced entry. The murder weapon was missing, but 9mm shell casings were found. The timeline narrowed: the couple had been killed between 2 and 5 a.m. on December 30th.
Surveillance footage captured a figure walking down an alley behind the home around the time of the murders. The person wore gray pants, a dark jacket, and a hood—features that would become critical in the investigation.
As the case unfolded, the focus shifted to Mon’nique’s past. Public records revealed her previous marriage to Michael McKe. Though the divorce had been described as amicable, detectives began to wonder: could resentment have simmered beneath the surface for years?
Chapter 6: The Surgeon Under Suspicion
Police tracked a vehicle seen arriving before and leaving after the homicides. The car was registered to Michael McKe. Cell phone records placed him in Columbus during the crucial window. Evidence showed McKe had possession of the vehicle before and after the murders.
The arrest came nine days after the crime. McKe was booked into the Rockford jail just after midnight on Saturday. His charges were upgraded to aggravated premeditated murder—a sign that investigators believed the act was planned.
Neighbors in Chicago were stunned. “He did not seem like somebody that would do something like this,” one said. “You never know. You meet people everywhere and you don’t know if they’re a serial killer.”
Chapter 7: Unanswered Questions
Why now? Why, after years apart and an apparently peaceful divorce, would Michael McKe allegedly choose this moment to act? What had changed in his life, or in Mon’nique’s, to trigger such violence?
Detectives continued to piece together the timeline. They searched for evidence of contact between McKe and Mon’nique after the divorce, for clues about how he entered the home, and for any signs of planning. The security cameras at the Tepe house held secrets—some revealed, some still hidden.
The community waited for answers, hearts heavy for the children left behind.
Chapter 8: The Courtroom Drama
McKe’s first court appearance was brief. He asserted his right to counsel and to remain silent, waived his extradition hearing, and prepared to be transported to Ohio. The judge set a status hearing for the following Monday, but McKe’s fate would soon be in the hands of the Ohio courts.
The Tepe family released a statement: “Today’s arrest represents an important step toward justice for Mo’Nique and Spencer. Nothing can undo the devastating loss of two lives taken far too soon. But we are grateful to the city of Columbus Police Department, its investigators, and assisting law enforcement community whose tireless efforts helped to capture the person involved. We thank the community for the continued support, prayers, and compassion shown throughout this tragedy.”
Chapter 9: The Evidence Mounts
The criminal complaint detailed how detectives identified McKe through neighborhood surveillance. The suspect was tracked to a vehicle, which arrived just prior to the homicides and left shortly after. Detectives located the vehicle in Rockford and found evidence linking McKe to it.
The timeline was tight. Police asked the public for any video or information from the area between 2 and 5 a.m. The person of interest video became a focal point—a shadowy figure moving through the darkness, possibly toward the Tepe home.
Behind the scenes, detectives worked methodically. Video evidence required technical expertise to download and authenticate. Fingerprints, if found, had to be matched—no easy task without a suspect’s prints in the database. Every lead was followed, every detail scrutinized.
Chapter 10: The Struggle for Justice
Proving guilt in a court of law is a complex process. The threshold for probable cause is low, but conviction requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt. Defense attorneys would challenge every piece of evidence—was it really McKe in the alley? Did he have his phone with him? Was he driving the car?
For the prosecution, the seven-hour drive from Chicago to Columbus was key. It was difficult to argue sudden passion when the suspect had so much time to reconsider. The evidence pointed to premeditation, not impulse.
Search warrants were executed in Chicago. Investigators combed through McKe’s computers, phones, and financial records, looking for signs of planning or motive.
Chapter 11: The Community Responds
The tragedy reverberated through Columbus. Candlelight vigils were held for Spencer and Mon’nique. Neighbors rallied around the children, raising more than $210,000 through GoFundMe to support their future.
Local leaders called for greater awareness of domestic violence and mental health. The case became a catalyst for change, inspiring conversations about safety, forgiveness, and the hidden dangers that can lurk in ordinary lives.
The Tepe children, just four and one, were placed in the care of loving relatives. Their laughter returned slowly, a reminder that hope can survive even in the darkest times.
Chapter 12: The Legacy
Spencer and Mon’nique Tepe were remembered not as victims, but as beacons of kindness and resilience. Spencer’s dental office dedicated a wing in his honor. Mon’nique’s friends established a scholarship fund for women pursuing careers in healthcare.
The story of their lives—and their loss—became a lesson in compassion and vigilance. Communities invested in resources for families in crisis, determined to prevent future tragedies.
Chapter 13: The Road Ahead
As the legal process unfolds, the questions remain. What drove Michael McKe to allegedly commit such a crime? Was there a warning missed, a sign overlooked? How can justice and healing coexist in the aftermath of such pain?
Detectives continue their work, prosecutors prepare for trial, and the community waits for closure. The story of the Columbus double homicide is not just about loss, but about the strength of a city to unite in the face of adversity.
Chapter 14: Reflection
True crime stories often end with answers, but rarely with complete understanding. The case of Michael McKe, Spencer and Mon’nique Tepe, and the children left behind is a reminder of the fragility of life and the enduring power of love.
If you or someone you know is struggling, reach out. Help is available. The legacy of the Tepe family is not just one of tragedy, but of hope—a hope that through awareness, compassion, and courage, we can build safer, stronger communities.
Chapter 15: Behind the Scenes—The Psychology of a Crime
As the investigation progressed, experts in criminal psychology began to weigh in on the case. The fact that Michael McKe had waited years after his divorce to allegedly commit such an act baffled many. Most crimes of passion occur close to the time of separation, but this was different—a chilling example of long-held resentment possibly turning deadly.
Dr. Robert Grande, a renowned forensic psychologist, commented, “Surgeons are often trained to remain calm under extreme pressure. That composure, when paired with unresolved emotional pain, can be dangerous. The surveillance footage showed a suspect who was methodical, not hurried, suggesting planning rather than impulse.”
The prosecution began to build a narrative of a man who may have felt replaced—his ex-wife had moved on, built a new life, and become a mother. Spencer Tepe, her new husband, shared similar backgrounds: both men attended Ohio State, both worked in medicine, both spoke Spanish. To McKe, Spencer might have symbolized everything he had lost.
Chapter 16: The Trial—A City Holds Its Breath
The trial drew nationwide attention. Reporters from major networks gathered at the courthouse, while the community watched anxiously for updates. Prosecutors presented their evidence: surveillance videos, cell phone records, shell casings, and digital footprints. They argued that the long drive, the timeline, and the lack of forced entry all pointed to premeditation.
Defense attorneys challenged the case, highlighting the circumstantial nature of the evidence. No murder weapon had been recovered. There were no eyewitnesses. The defense questioned whether the person in the alley was truly McKe, and whether cell phone data could definitively place him inside the home.
Throughout the proceedings, the Tepe family sat quietly, surrounded by supporters. The children’s future, the community’s sense of safety, and the search for justice all hung in the balance.
Chapter 17: The Verdict—A City Seeks Closure
After weeks of emotional testimony, the jury reached its decision. Michael McKe was found guilty of two counts of aggravated premeditated murder. The courtroom erupted in a mix of relief and sorrow. The Tepe family embraced, tears streaming down their faces. The children, too young to understand, were comforted by relatives.
The judge spoke solemnly: “No verdict can restore what was lost, but may this decision bring some measure of peace.”
Chapter 18: Aftermath—Ripples Through the Community
Columbus began the slow process of healing. Candlelight vigils were held at the Tepe home and Spencer’s dental office. Community leaders called for renewed efforts to support families in crisis and to recognize the warning signs of domestic violence.
The GoFundMe campaign for the Tepe children continued to grow, a testament to the compassion of strangers. Local organizations offered counseling and support, determined to help the children build new lives.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(748x233:750x235)/Michael-David-McKee-Monique-Tepe-011226-f81526b4ed8040db8ccd8418471f8bd4.jpg)
Chapter 19: Lessons Learned—Moving Forward
The story of the Tepe family and Michael McKe became a catalyst for change. Police departments reviewed their procedures for wellness checks. Mental health professionals launched new outreach programs. The community pledged never to forget the lives lost, nor the lessons learned.
Spencer and Mon’nique’s legacy lived on in every act of kindness, every scholarship awarded, and every moment of unity that followed. Their children, surrounded by love, grew stronger each day.
Chapter 20: Echoes of Grief—A Family’s Journey
In the months following the verdict, the Tepe family sought to rebuild their lives. The children, now in the care of loving relatives, began to adjust to a new reality—a world without the warmth of their parents but surrounded by the unwavering support of a community determined to help them heal.
Spencer’s colleagues at the dental office remembered him fondly: his humor, his dedication, his ability to make patients feel safe. Mon’nique’s friends shared stories of her generosity and the way she always made time for others. Their absence was felt deeply, but their memory became a source of strength.
The GoFundMe fund continued to grow, ensuring the children would have opportunities and stability in the years ahead. Each donation was a message of solidarity—a promise that the community would not forget.
Chapter 21: Reflections—Unanswered Questions
Despite the conviction, questions lingered. What drives a person to hold onto resentment for years, only to let it explode in violence? Could anything have been done to prevent the tragedy? The case sparked conversations about mental health, the importance of communication, and the need for vigilance even when relationships appear to end peacefully.
Local organizations responded by expanding resources for families and individuals in crisis. Workshops on emotional resilience, conflict resolution, and recognizing warning signs were held throughout Columbus. The city vowed to learn from its loss, turning heartbreak into action.
Chapter 22: Legacy—Light in the Darkness
Spencer and Mon’nique’s names became synonymous with kindness and community spirit. A scholarship in Mon’nique’s honor supported young women pursuing careers in education and healthcare. Spencer’s dental office dedicated a new children’s wing in his name, filled with books and bright colors—a place where laughter could return.
Each year, the community gathered for a candlelight vigil, sharing memories and reaffirming their commitment to protect and support one another. The Tepe children, growing stronger with each passing day, became symbols of resilience.
Chapter 23: Message to the Reader—Hope Beyond Tragedy
True crime stories often leave us with more questions than answers. The tragedy in Columbus is a sobering reminder of how fragile life can be and how important it is to care for one another, especially in times of change and loss.
If you or someone you know is struggling with anger, grief, or fear, remember: there is help. Reach out, speak up, and know that you are not alone. The legacy of Spencer and Mon’nique Tepe is not just one of sorrow, but of hope—a hope that through compassion, vigilance, and community, we can prevent future heartbreak.
In the end, this story is about more than a crime. It is about love, loss, and the enduring strength of the human spirit. It is a call to cherish every moment, to build bridges where there are divides, and to never let darkness go unchallenged.
