In the wake of Michael David McKee’s arrest for the premeditated double murder of his ex-wife Monique Tepe and her husband, Spencer Tepe, shocking new details have emerged from his professional life. Colleagues at the hospital where the 39-year-old vascular surgeon worked have come forward, describing how McKee repeatedly voiced feelings of being “disrespected” by others and made veiled threats that those individuals would “receive the fitting consequence” or “get what’s coming to them.” These statements, reportedly made over the course of about one month leading up to the December 30, 2025, shootings in Columbus, Ohio, now cast a chilling light on the suspect’s mindset in the days before the tragedy.
McKee, a licensed vascular surgeon practicing primarily at OSF Saint Anthony Medical Center in Rockford, Illinois (with prior affiliations and licenses in California), was described by hospital staff as outwardly professional and competent in his surgical duties. Patients often praised him as “personable” and “excellent” in reviews, and he had built a solid reputation in a demanding specialty requiring precision and years of training. He graduated from Ohio State University College of Medicine in 2014 and maintained active medical licenses without any prior disciplinary actions noted publicly.
Yet behind this polished facade, coworkers now recount a pattern of private conversations where McKee expressed deep-seated grievances. According to accounts shared in the aftermath of his January 10, 2026, arrest, he frequently brought up instances where he felt undervalued, overlooked, or slighted—whether by colleagues, superiors, or figures from his personal past. In these discussions, which occurred in break rooms, during shifts, or in casual hallway exchanges, McKee allegedly escalated his rhetoric. He would say things like, “They think they can disrespect me, but they’ll get what’s coming,” or variations implying a deserved reckoning. These remarks, while vague at the time, were dismissed by some as venting from a high-stress job, but they took on sinister new meaning after the murders.
The timing—roughly one month before the killings—aligns with what investigators describe as a period of mounting premeditation. McKee allegedly traveled from Illinois to Ohio, executed the shootings in the early morning hours (between 2 a.m. and 5 a.m.), and fled, leaving no forced entry and sparing the couple’s two young children (ages 1 and 4). The couple was discovered during a wellness check after Spencer’s colleagues at his Athens dental practice raised the alarm when he failed to show up for work.
The personal motive appears rooted in McKee’s failed marriage to Monique. The two wed in 2015 and divorced in 2017 after a brief, reportedly difficult union with no children. Monique later found happiness with Spencer, marrying him in early 2021 and building a family. Spencer’s brother-in-law, Rob Misleh, described McKee as emotionally abusive during the marriage, and family members quickly suspected his involvement upon learning of the deaths. The upgraded charges to two counts of aggravated murder with premeditation underscore the calculated nature of the act.
Hospital sources indicate that McKee’s complaints of disrespect often carried a tone of entitlement and unresolved anger. While no one reported overt threats of violence to authorities beforehand, the recurring theme of “payback” or “fitting consequences” now stands out as a potential red flag in hindsight. Colleagues expressed shock at the revelation, with one anonymous staff member noting how McKee’s demeanor in professional settings masked any inner turmoil. The hospital, upon his arrest, removed his profile from public directories and issued a statement confirming cooperation with law enforcement, emphasizing no prior indications of danger.
This pattern of perceived slights and vows of retribution adds a psychological dimension to the case. Experts in behavioral analysis suggest that individuals harboring long-term resentment—especially over romantic rejection combined with professional or social grievances—can reach a breaking point where abstract threats turn into action. McKee’s statements, made in the final weeks before the crime, may reflect escalating fixation on those he believed had wronged him, culminating in the targeted attack on Monique and the man she built a new life with.
Neighbors in Chicago’s upscale Lincoln Park, where McKee resided in a high-rise condo, echoed the surprise. One described casual poolside chats with him as unremarkable, only to be stunned by the news of his alleged involvement. “He seemed normal—talked about the weather, barbecues—then this,” the neighbor said.
As McKee awaits extradition from Winnebago County Jail in Illinois to Franklin County, Ohio, he has indicated through his public defender an intent to plead not guilty. He waived extradition in a brief January 12, 2026, court appearance, appearing calm in a yellow jumpsuit and shackles. The Tepe family, in statements, expressed gratitude for the arrest as “an important step toward justice” while mourning the irreplaceable loss and focusing on the well-being of the children.
The revelations from McKee’s workplace paint a picture of a man quietly nursing wounds of perceived disrespect, allowing bitterness to fester until it allegedly erupted in violence. What began as workplace grumbling may have foreshadowed a devastating act that shattered a family and stunned two communities. As the investigation continues, these accounts from colleagues serve as a haunting reminder of how hidden resentments can remain concealed until it’s too late.
